Places to eat

Sara’s Gelato

Our favorite ice cream shop in Door County! Delightful flavors, originally from Green Bay, now in Fish Creek since 2021.

Sara’s Gelato is a beloved ice cream shop that has captured our hearts and taste buds in Door County. With origins in Green Bay, we couldn’t have been happier when they expanded to Fish Creek in 2021. Offering a wide variety of delightful flavors and exceptional quality, Sara’s Gelato is the perfect place to treat yourself and your family during your vacation.

Similar Recommendations

Blue Horse Beach Cafe

Blue Horse Beach Cafe

Delight in delicious breakfast, lunch, cafe & bakery items. Open year-round, across from the water in Fish Creek.

Places to eat
Wally’s Weenie Wagon

Wally’s Weenie Wagon

Savor Chicago-style hot dogs, specialty dogs, gyros & more in Baileys Harbor! Authentic Vienna Beef hot dogs for a genuine taste.

Places to eat
Fat Belly

Fat Belly

Sushi, Ramen, Poke: Savor fresh seafood in a cozy, upscale setting. Formerly Fat Belly Burritos and Bowls, they are opening this new concept in 2023.

Places to eat
Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub

Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub

Enjoy delicious burgers and live music at this charming Sturgeon Bay pub, complete with outdoor seating!

Places to eat
Wild Tomato Wood-fired Pizza and Grille

Wild Tomato Wood-fired Pizza and Grille

Savor scrumptious wood-fired pizzas & cheese curds at this popular eatery. A must-try in Door County!

Places to eat
The Fireside Restaurant

The Fireside Restaurant

Recently relocated to Egg Harbor, enjoy their Cajun-inspired menu & friendly atmosphere. A local gem!

Places to eat

Subscribe to receive news and updates

See What Our Guests Are Saying!

The Flats

Kari Olsen
5star rating
February 22, 2021
Great visit! Loved the place. We enjoyed it so much that we didn't spent almost the whole weekend hanging out there.

Mostly great

Judith STEED
4star rating
November 19, 2021
Everything was great except the noise of heavy equipment starting before 7:30 am from the construction. We came for a quiet restful time and the noise made it impossible to sleep in. We were told the day before, I believe, that we could park in fr...

When can we move in?

Pam Tarpey
5star rating
October 15, 2022
We loved everything about the place. Clean, quiet and convenient. Loved the artwork and the simple, clean aesthetic. We will be returning for a longer visit.

We’ll be back!

Mark Alan
5star rating
March 4, 2023
What a fabulous space and perfect for the two of us! We loved the rustic beams and high ceiling loft. The two fireplaces made it a wonderful winter getaway.

Perfect location

Jason Race
5star rating
August 14, 2020
This place was perfectly located and well maintained. We will definitely be coming back in the future!

Excellent experience

Jennifer Budzinaki
5star rating
April 21, 2020
We had a wonderful time in Door County. The Flats was an awesome place to stay. From the owners to the Comfort of the bed I couldn't have asked for a bet experience.

Great Space for Couple’s Retreat

David Firari
5star rating
February 8, 2023
Perfect space for two to enjoy Door County.

Excellent

Rebekah Morrow
5star rating
October 18, 2021
The Flats on Church Street was a wonderful place to stay in Door County. 100% recommend!

Bright and Airy

Diane Sixel
5star rating
January 10, 2022
Thank you for the comfortable stay. Loved the window wall and all the natural light. We had all the amenities we needed plus more. Plan to return again on a future visit to Door County.

Wonderful!

Lillian Hackman
5star rating
April 18, 2021
Everything was awesome! It was our first time in Door County and this little gem was a such a great place to call home. We hope to visit again! The only odd (very minor) thing was that the HDMI cable was unplugged from the TV. It took a little...

Girls Weekend Getaway

Chelsey Gebel
5star rating
June 28, 2021
I recently stayed in the corner suite for a much-anticipated girls weekend. From check-in to departure, everything about our stay was seamless and enjoyable. The accommodations were clean, cozy, and quaint, and the location cannot be beat. Ample p...

Outstanding!

Dana Innocenti
5star rating
June 15, 2020
The Flats On Church Street was even better than we ever anticipated! It was modern. clean, spacious and beyond comfortable. The king bed was one of the most comfortable beds I've ever slept in. The amenities were perfect and everything you cou...

See What Our Guests Are Saying!

COACH HOUSE

Thomas M.Barden
5star rating
November 19, 2021
Wow what a surprise, we loved that place! At first we thought with all the windows and beam ceilings it might not stay warm this time of year. We were VERY wrong, that was not a problem and we loved the openness of the place and there's curtai...

Modern Escape

Mary Best
5star rating
August 25, 2020
I was definitely drawn to the modern aesthetic and The Flats did not disappoint. It was also in a great location. Rob, the host was totally accessible when I called and couldn't figure out how to work the fire table. I would highly recommend.

Pumpkin fest

Deborah Moret
5star rating
October 11, 2022
We loved the location of this rental and the bed was very comfortable. No problems!

Wonderful Lodging Experience

Jeanette K Eliason
5star rating
January 17, 2023
We loved staying at Flats on Church Street! Beautiful surroundings, comfortable beds and furniture! Well planned and welcoming.

Perfect for our family of 3

Tammi Kral
5star rating
September 4, 2022
We had a wonderful stay and loved the location walking distance to downtown Egg Harbor.

Door County Needs More Places Like This

Dale Miller
4star rating
May 5, 2022
Clean , modern and conveniently walkable to shops. It would be better if there was a small freezer or an ice machine close by. No local TV stations nor basic cable TV. The electric tea kettle was great but it would be better to have a full ...

Howard House Rocks

Laurie Hegge
5star rating
August 22, 2020
We love the Howard House. So many thoughtful touches make guests feel right at home. We slept like rocks in the cozy beds and the location is perfect. I had to connect with work when I was there, and the internet connection is solid. No small thin...

It’s All in the Details

Sue Kreibich
5star rating
June 15, 2021
We wanted to thank you for the wonderful stay at your property. We loved how modern everything felt. You thought of everything-we loved the eco friendly products, the water in the frig, the way you hung the towels, with the eco friendly products...

Great Sturgeon Bay Getaway

Bill Mueller
5star rating
November 22, 2022
We stayed in the Postcard Suite over a weekend and loved it! Centrally located so you can walk to many places, and the suite was very nice with a comfy bed and everything we needed. We will definitely rent again.

Very nice

Steve spomer
4star rating
January 3, 2020
Very clean...private and quiet....close to town...,nice amenities. Need a basket for towels in the bathroom...a little dresser with drawers

Best Place to Stay

Karen Aleo
5star rating
September 16, 2021
We absolutely loved our stay at Flats on Church Street. Like many other places in Door County, the room was clean and lovely, but what you will get here that you won't elsewhere is a large open space, modern design, a quiet space where you can't h...

Great place

Chris Liechty
5star rating
August 1, 2021
We had a great stay at the Flats on Church Street. Modern, clean and convenient to Egg Harbor and the rest of Door County

© DoCo Vacations. All Rights Reserved. Website by Hudson Creative Studio.