Places to eat
Hill Street
Hill Street is a lively, locally loved bar and eatery on Fish Creek’s Main Street that hits the sweet spot between cozy pub vibes and casual-cool dining, complete with great food, live music, and indoor/outdoor bars.
Hill Street delivers that perfect Fish Creek blend: laid-back yet polished. With two bars (indoor and outdoor), a menu of crowd‑pleasing American eats made with fresh, local ingredients, and weekly live music, it’s the go-to spot from lunch through late-night.
Similar Recommendations
Cultured
Cultured in Sister Bay is a micro sourdough bakery and fermenter serving bagels, sandwiches, sourdough loaves, and drip coffee in a casual, charming storefront.
One Star Burgers & Dogs
One Star Burgers & Dogs in Sister Bay dishes out smash burgers, hot dogs, soft-serve treats, and floats in a casual, family-friendly drive-in setting.
Inland Pizza
Inland Pizza in Baileys Harbor serves up sourdough pizzas with inventive toppings and fresh salads in a cozy, family-run setting.
Wilson’s Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlor
Wilson’s in Ephraim, a historic spot since 1906, delights with old-fashioned soda, home-brewed root beer, and jukebox classics. A nostalgic favorite for all.
Prince of Pierogi Restaurant
Prince of Pierogi specializes in made-to-order Polish pierogi—both sweet and savory—as well as cabbage rolls, kielbasa, and more, served quickly in a welcoming grab-and-go setting in Ephraim or Sturgeon Bay.
Blue Horse Beach Cafe
Delight in delicious breakfast, lunch, cafe & bakery items. Open year-round, across from the water in Fish Creek.