Places to eat
Blue Horse Beach Cafe
Delight in delicious breakfast, lunch, cafe & bakery items. Open year-round, across from the water in Fish Creek.
Blue Horse Beach Cafe is a charming gem located across from the water on the highway in Fish Creek. With an array of mouthwatering breakfast and lunch options, as well as an inviting cafe and bakery, it’s no wonder we adore this place! Open year-round, Blue Horse Beach Cafe is the perfect spot to enjoy a scrumptious meal while taking in the scenic surroundings.
Similar Recommendations
Cultured
Cultured in Sister Bay is a micro sourdough bakery and fermenter serving bagels, sandwiches, sourdough loaves, and drip coffee in a casual, charming storefront.
One Star Burgers & Dogs
One Star Burgers & Dogs in Sister Bay dishes out smash burgers, hot dogs, soft-serve treats, and floats in a casual, family-friendly drive-in setting.
Inland Pizza
Inland Pizza in Baileys Harbor serves up sourdough pizzas with inventive toppings and fresh salads in a cozy, family-run setting.
Hill Street
Hill Street is a lively, locally loved bar and eatery on Fish Creek’s Main Street that hits the sweet spot between cozy pub vibes and casual-cool dining, complete with great food, live music, and indoor/outdoor bars.
Wilson’s Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlor
Wilson’s in Ephraim, a historic spot since 1906, delights with old-fashioned soda, home-brewed root beer, and jukebox classics. A nostalgic favorite for all.
Prince of Pierogi Restaurant
Prince of Pierogi specializes in made-to-order Polish pierogi—both sweet and savory—as well as cabbage rolls, kielbasa, and more, served quickly in a welcoming grab-and-go setting in Ephraim or Sturgeon Bay.