The Fireside Restaurant

4113 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212, USA

+1 920-868-1471

Wally’s Weenie Wagon

Savor Chicago-style hot dogs, specialty dogs, gyros & more in Baileys Harbor! Authentic Vienna Beef hot dogs for a genuine taste.

Places to eat

8123 WI-57, Baileys Harbor, WI 54202, USA

+1 920-493-3016

Sara’s Gelato

Our favorite ice cream shop in Door County! Delightful flavors, originally from Green Bay, now in Fish Creek since 2021.

Places to eat

4192 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212, USA

+1 414-721-1802

Fat Belly

Sushi, Ramen, Poke: Savor fresh seafood in a cozy, upscale setting. Formerly Fat Belly Burritos and Bowls, they are opening this new concept in 2023.

Places to eat

10621 N Highland Rd, Sister Bay, WI 54234, USA

+1 920-854-3500

Kitty O’Reillys Irish Pub

Enjoy delicious burgers and live music at this charming Sturgeon Bay pub, complete with outdoor seating!

Places to eat

59 E Oak St, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, USA

+1 920-743-7441

Wild Tomato Wood-fired Pizza and Grille

Savor scrumptious wood-fired pizzas & cheese curds at this popular eatery. A must-try in Door County!

Places to eat

Modern Craftsman Home in Egg Harbor

9595, 10677 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234, USA

+1 920-854-4685

Book Today

Guide to DoCo

FAQ

Spotless and lovely

Jo Ann Bishop

April 21, 2021

The Egg Harbor Hideaway was a perfect place for a long weekend. The unit was super clean, perfectly appointed, and very welcoming. There was a bachelorette weekend downstairs but we were not bothered by noise, good soundproofing.

Egg Harbor Hideaway

Awesome Stay

Shalynn Schill

June 13, 2020

Very accommodating and beautiful house! Would love to book another vacation with them!

Great Place to Stay

Danielle Bozek

January 11, 2021

A really cool place! We loved the layout and ability to travel with a whole group due to the other rooms next door. Great location and easy to get to nearby places in town!

Perfect for our family of 3

Tammi Kral

September 4, 2022

We had a wonderful stay and loved the location walking distance to downtown Egg Harbor.

Coach House Suite – Downtown Sturgeon Bay

Convenient location, home full of character

Kristin Dabols

August 20, 2021

We loved our stay in the Coach House, so full of character and there was plenty of space, plus a super convenient location within walking distance of all kinds of things to see and do.

Girls Weekend Getaway

Chelsey Gebel

June 28, 2021

I recently stayed in the corner suite for a much-anticipated girls weekend. From check-in to departure, everything about our stay was seamless and enjoyable. The accommodations were clean, cozy, and quaint, and the location cannot be beat. Ample p...

Corner Suite – Downtown Sturgeon Bay

We LOVE the Flats on Church Street

Courtney Parkhill

January 4, 2021

This was our second stay at the Flats, and as before, everything was wonderful. Rob and Suzie do such a great job. We can’t wait to come back!

Modern Craftsman Home and Hideaway

Another fantastic stay in Egg Harbor

Ada [email protected]

August 26, 2021

We are repeat renters at 7908 Church Street in Egg Harbor. We keep coming back because of the fantastic amenities of the house, perfect location walkable to all Egg Harbor has to offer, and easy quick responsiveness of Rob and Suzie. Highly recomm...

Flats 2 on Church Street

John Gorski

September 14, 2021

Heated floors are a nice touch. Definitely enjoyed the stay and look forward to the next time that we would be back!

Flats on Church Street – #201

When can we move in?

Pam Tarpey

October 15, 2022

We loved everything about the place. Clean, quiet and convenient. Loved the artwork and the simple, clean aesthetic. We will be returning for a longer visit.

Another great stay!

Kathleen Kluck

December 1, 2021

Our second time at one of The Flats units, and we loved it again! Hope to return in the future.

Coach House Suite – Downtown Sturgeon Bay

Couple’s Getaway

Chris Grove

May 21, 2021

A great private little loft. Close to everything, but felt totally secluded and quiet. Perfect space for to escape to. Will definitely research these owners' properties when planning our next visit.

Egg Harbor Hideaway

All Reviews

Dr.

Mike Gonda

November 25, 2019

Great place to stay in Sturgeon Bay. It’s located right in the downtown area and is central to everything. The Coach House Suite was comfortable and had plenty of room for our party of 4. Many amenities, 2 fireplaces, full kitchen with Keurig m...

Another fantastic stay in Egg Harbor

Ada Zavala

August 21, 2020

This was our second year staying at Rob and Suzie's home and hideaway in Egg Harbor. The home was beautiful, clean, well equipped, and situated in a fantastic location. Rob and Suzie are great hosts.

Modern Craftsman Home and Hideaway

Anonymous

Amy Meinen

August 6, 2020

Perfect accommodations, especially during the pandemic!

Flats on Church Street #101

Great place!

Misty Konen

October 19, 2022

Beautiful space! Fantastic hosts! Thanks for being so accommodating.Had a wonderful time..we will definitely return!

The Flats on Church Street #103

Wonderful Lodging Experience

Jeanette K Eliason

January 17, 2023

We loved staying at Flats on Church Street! Beautiful surroundings, comfortable beds and furniture! Well planned and welcoming.

Flats on Church Street – #201

Great house!

Tony Gibertini

November 22, 2021

We go to the Door every November. This was our first time staying in Baileys Harbor. This house was wonderful. The location was perfect. Easy access to the entire peninsula via the interior roads, not just 42 or 57…we felt like locals! The house ...

Howard House – Downtown Baileys Harbor

Great November stay

Frank M

November 14, 2022

My wife, 6mo, and I spent 4 nights at Howard House in mid November. It was the perfect place for us in a great location. The entire house is clean, well organized, and setup to cool your own meals if you choose. It’s also close to just about any p...

Howard House – Downtown Baileys Harbor

Awesome experience!!

Connie Dollevoet

October 24, 2021

Beautiful place to stay!! Love the location! Loved the industrial modern look and the heated floors!! It was nicely decorated and clean with all you would need to cook, relax and enjoy Egg Harbor! Would definitely recommend to stay there!!🤗

Loved Our Stay

Jen & Keith Miller

November 11, 2019

Beautiful, clean, modern accommodations. Easy walk to food, shops, and the waterfront. Situated next to a gorgeous library. Quick drive to other areas of Door County for more water, shopping, and hiking. Thanks for a great stay!

Best Place to Stay

Karen Aleo

September 16, 2021

We absolutely loved our stay at Flats on Church Street. Like many other places in Door County, the room was clean and lovely, but what you will get here that you won't elsewhere is a large open space, modern design, a quiet space where you can't h...

Couple’s Getaway

Chris Grove

May 21, 2021

A great private little loft. Close to everything, but felt totally secluded and quiet. Perfect space for to escape to. Will definitely research these owners' properties when planning our next visit.

Egg Harbor Hideaway

Wonderful!

Lillian Hackman

April 18, 2021

Everything was awesome! It was our first time in Door County and this little gem was a such a great place to call home. We hope to visit again! The only odd (very minor) thing was that the HDMI cable was unplugged from the TV. It took a little...